Ammo Navigation Weblog Company Support Store Rogue Amoeba
Rogue Amoeba
Sun, 01 Jul 2007

Yesterday (late last night, really) I posted a timeline of my iPhone purchase. As noted, I had the iPhone in 7 minutes, but activation was taking hours. This morning when I woke up and discovered the iPhone was still an iBrick, I decided to stop waiting and do something active. An hour later, I'm up and running.

Here's what I did:

1) As I only have cell service, I tried the new SIM in my old phone, which allowed me to place calls.

2) I then checked the AT&T forums for contact info. I called 1-877-800-3701, selected option 1, and then waited on hold.

3) For the next 45 minutes, I heard 30 seconds of bad music, followed by a pause during which I would experience that emotion once called "hope". I'd then get a standard "Your call is important to us" type message, followed by 30 seconds of more bad music, another pause, and so on. Lather, rinse, repeat.

4) When I got through, I explained my situation to the CS rep, who looked over my account, tweaked some things, and checked my IMEI and ICCID numbers (they're on the iPhone box). He then told me to swap my SIM back into the iPhone and wait just a couple minutes for a call-back.

5) A few minutes later, I had the long-awaited email, as well as a call-back from the CS rep on the iPhone. Everything finally worked. I asked what the issue was, and the CS rep said that the person who had activated the account had neglected to add one feature, and failed to click the all-important final "Activate" button. Oops.

Lest you think I'm an idiot, when he said "the person who activated the phone", he didn't mean me. It sounds like at least some activations must be processed manually, after the iTunes portion is performed by the customer. My phone number is in New Jersey, while my billing address is in Boston, so this may cause issues and require manual activation. That manual activation didn't go properly - my CS rep said they were "seeing a lot of problems with that".

As mentioned yesterday, I have no plans to pay an activation fee and at this time, none was on my account. If one is added, I'll be fighting it, as $36 to activate a phone myself, then wait over a day with not one but two bricked phones, is not my idea of a bargain.

I don't know what would have happened had I passively waited longer. It seems likely that this might have gone unnoticed for many more hours, perhaps even days. The best I can offer those waiting is to take action.

Posted by Paul | Permalink | View/Post Comments (10)

Comments


Paul (Rogue Amoeba Staff)
Sun Jul 1 13:08:15 2007

Testing UTM in iPhone Safari. Seems to work fine.

John Gruber
Sun Jul 1 18:12:36 2007

How will you dispute the activation fee or get out of paying it? Is there some sort of trick, or will you just call customer service and demand they retract it?

Paul (Rogue Amoeba Staff)
Sun Jul 1 18:25:23 2007

John: If it comes to it, I'll be bitching to customer service. Maybe even refusing that charge on my credit card? We'll see I guess.

David
Sun Jul 1 18:26:40 2007

I agree with you on fighting the charge. If that happens to me (I intend to buy one asap) I would definitely fight the charge with AT&T, and maybe even drop an email to Apple.

Afsheen
Sun Jul 1 19:44:57 2007

I've been with AT&T (well, it was Cingular, until the name change) for about 7 years, and they've always been very accommodating with credits to my account when things go wrong.

What I've found is that the first person I talk to is generally very unhelpful, so once I explain my problem and they make a lowball offer, I politely ask to speak to a supervisor.  The supervisor generally offers somewhere in the range of $50 to $100 more than I was ever expecting to get out of them, so everything gets resolved pretty quickly.  (Not counting the 20-30 minutes on hold before I get to talk to someone, of course...)

mark
Sun Jul 1 20:03:09 2007

When I had trouble activating a phone with T-mobile and lost a day of service, they took $5 off the bill (on a $60 family plan) when I mentioned it.  Didn't threaten them or anything; just said it was really frustrating that I was being billed for service but I wasn't hadn't received any service yet.  (Isn't there some kind of law about this somewhere?)

Anyway, that's customer service, and why I'm still on T-mobile today.  Though I feel like I'm being sucked into an Apple Store ...

John Gruber
Sun Jul 1 22:20:05 2007

To be clear, I wasn't arguing that you didn't have good reason to dispute the activation fee charge. I was just wondering if you were aware of a specific trick to get around it.

Michel Christensen
Mon Jul 2 06:43:51 2007

I work in a telco customer service, and even though we (in Denmark) aren't obligated to cancel the fee, since you actually GOT activated, and we aren't obligated to adjust any monthly fee, if a service is out of order for less than 72 hours, we do it all the time. It's all about customer service :-)

Adam W
Mon Jul 2 11:53:07 2007

While I can see some of your frustration, but the entire -

"...wait over a day with not one but two bricked phones, is not my idea of a bargain."

- portion of this article seems a bit harsh.  You obviously could have had this fixed on day 1 by just letting them know you had a problem. 
Although even if things had gone perfectly, 36 bucks to activate a phone seems steep to me.  I also feel dirty for even kind of defending AT&T, as the entire reason I won't be getting an iPhone is because I refuse to do business with them ever again...

Paul (Rogue Amoeba Staff)
Mon Jul 2 12:25:52 2007

Adam: I don't think it's harsh at all. I followed their instructions, and I had no (easy) way of letting them know of the issue. I had no phone service, and the only contact I received (after 13 hours of waiting) was from a "do_not_reply@" address.. They bricked my old phone first, then failed to properly activate my new phone, leaving me with nothing working.

Further, they told me my activation was processing, and to just wait patiently. When I finally decided to get impatient, after over a day, that's then I finally started trying different things. Swapping a SIM card from the new phone to the old phone? That's not difficult, but it is odd. It's certainly not anything they told me to do. They told me to wait, I waited. 13 hours later they told me to wait again, I waited. 26 hours later, I said "Screw this" and stopped waiting. Only then did anything happen.

Their system should be able to detect that this activation had not processed as it should have, instead of me forcing them to take a look at it.


This post is archived, and commenting has been closed.
Copyright © 2008 Rogue Amoeba Software, LLC. All rights reserved.